What Underlayment is Best for Metal Roofs?

Throughout this month, we’ve delved into the diverse world of metal roofing, comparing its various types and styles, exploring its contrasts with asphalt, and looking at the types of metal roof coatings. As we round out the month, today’s #MagnificentMetalMonday focuses on the crucial role of underlayment in metal roof installations. Understanding the significance of choosing the right underlayment is paramount, as it holds equal weight to the selection of the roofing material itself, be it for a residential or commercial project.

What is Underlayment?

Image Credit: Skywalker Roofing

Underlayment is the layer beneath a roofing system that serves as an extra weather resistance barrier — a secondary level of waterproofing protection directly on top of the wood roof deck. As a crucial barrier that contributes to the performance and longevity of the entire roof system, it is important to choose the right underlayment for your roof and your particular climate. This layer of protection isn’t optional — it’s essential to a proper metal roofing system. Three common types of underlayment for metal roofs include felt, self-adhering membrane, and synthetic sheet.

What’s the Best Underlayment Choice for your Metal Roof?

It’s important to create the best support system to provide the best protection for your roof and home. Here are some things to keep in mind when considering the three common metal roofing underlayment options:

Felt Underlayment

Felt Underlayment; Photo Credit: Skywalker Roofing

Felt underlayment is the most common material used for steeper-sloped metal roofs. Known to be cost-effective and reliably water-resistant, but it does not last as long as other underlayment materials and is likely to fail before a metal roof needs replacing. Climate is another consideration as it tends to not endure high-temperature environments very well. Some other notable disadvantages include small roll sizes leading to increased labor and lack of recyclability.

Self-Adhering Membrane

Self-adhering membrane underlayment is a peel-and-stick product that includes either a rubberized asphalt or butyl-based adhesive, mounted on a polyethylene carrier sheet, and designed to be applied directly to roof decking. Known to perform better than felt underlayment in high-temperature environments, the self-adhering membrane presents more of an air barrier. It is more helpful for ice dam protection in sensitive locations like eaves, valleys, and dormers. Other factors to consider with this underlayment include installation and its performance in low-temperature environments. If not installed correctly, it can result in your membrane peeling back over time, leaving a roof more vulnerable to infiltration.

Synthetic Sheet

Photo Credit: Skywalker Roofing

The “new kid on the block.” Synthetic underlayment is a newer technology that’s become more prevalent in recent years. It’s manufactured by weaving or spinning together either polyethylene or polypropylene with a polymer, to form a protective barrier between the roofing material and decking. The advantages include durability, high temperatures tolerant, and the longest lifespan. While more expensive than some comparable underlayment options, synthetic underlayment currently provides the most reliable performance at keeping out moisture and has better product longevity.

Tips on Choosing the Underlayment Right For Your Roof

According to Sheffield Metals, a METALCON exhibitor and leading distributor of coated and bare metal products, as well as engineered standing seam metal roof (SSMR) & wall systems, they suggest asking yourself these questions to help determine which underlayment is right for you:

  • How long do I want the roof underlayment to last? How about the actual roof?
  • Does my or my customer’s budget allow for an expensive underlayment?
  • Will my or my customer’s underlayment be exposed to long periods of sun or heat?
  • Do I want to be able to buy my underlayment at a big box/home improvement store?
  • How concerned am I about fire resistance or having a Class-A fire rating?

Continuing Education with Roofing Experts

According to the Metal Roofing Alliance, a new CEU continuing education course is now available for architects and other roofing professionals about roofing underlayments called The Importance of Roof Underlayment for Energy Efficiency and Fire Resistance. Offered by Westlake Royal Roofing Solutions™, a leader in efficient and resilient roofing systems and components, the course explores the roof underlayment as an integral part of the total roof system design and educates architects on the performance, benefits, fire resistance and weather resilience of various underlayment types. The course explores the different types of underlayment, highlighting options that will optimize the performance and compatibility with roofing materials. It will also examine the attributes and strengths of the different underlayment categories and educate participants on how quality products can enhance energy efficiency and fire resistance.

Meet with Experts at METALCON

For over 30 years, METALCON has been a leading event for the metal construction industry. With nearly 20 exhibitors specializing in metal roofing materials, including underlayment products, slated to participate in this year’s event, you’ll have the exclusive opportunity to explore these offerings firsthand. Leading companies such as Sheffield Metals, Isaiah Industries, Titanium® and RhinoRoof, and VB Synthetics will be on hand showcasing their latest roofing solutions and products. Join us this year in Atlanta, Georgia, October 30 – November 1, for 3 days of connecting with industry experts and peers from around the world.

For more information:

Synthetic vs. Felt Underlayment for Metal Roofing: Which Is Best? by Sheffield Metals


What is the Best Underlayment for a Metal Roof? by McElroy Metals



More Posts from the METALCON blog:

What is Metal Fabrication?

Metal Fabrication serves as the backbone for various sectors with the construction industry being one of the largest consumers of fabricated metal products. Learn more about this multi-billion dollar industry, the processes and latest advancements. Also learn how you can register for METALCON where dozens of metal fabricators will gather in late October.

Read More »

METALCON presentations focus on ‘building performance’

NEWTON, Mass., June 5, 2024 — For any construction project, the goal has always been using top quality building materials for the best price. It’s all about “building performance.” “Providing education on building performance at METALCON is essential,” says Judy Geller, Vice President, METALCON. “It will help building and design professionals address performance challenges, mitigate risks and enhance resilience leading to cost savings over the lifespan of the building. Standards and codes specific to the building site provide a helpful

Read More »

METALCON Announces Keynote and Special Session Speakers for Upcoming 2024 Conference

Attendees can look forward to being educated, informed, and inspired by the captivating keynote and special session speakers. Newton, MA: METALCON, the premier event for the metal construction industry, has announced the keynote and special session speakers for this year’s conference, which will be held from October 30th to November 1st in Atlanta, GA. Attendees can anticipate a series of compelling presentations designed to educate, inform, and inspire. Premier Keynote On Wednesday, October 30th, former NFL MVP Quarterback and Super

Read More »

Metal Construction Industry 101: Diving Into the Basics & Emerging Trends of 2024

Metal Construction Industry 101: Dive into the fundamentals of metal construction and get up to date on current and emerging trends is crucial for industry professionals. Explore these topics by watching the recent Metal Construction Industry 101 webinar with experts Todd Miller and Lauren Rubino. Learn why attending the METALCON trade show is essential, especially for future leaders in the industry.

Read More »

Honoring Those Who Have Served on Memorial Day: METALCON’s Commitment to Giving Back

On this Memorial Day, we take a moment to honor those who have laid down their lives in service to our nation, ensuring the freedoms we enjoy today. Over the years, METALCON has built a strong tradition of giving back, raising funds, and providing much-needed assistance to those who have served in the military. Join us once again in our annual fundraising efforts to benefit Semper Fi & America’s Fund. Donate online or in person at METALCON 2024.

Read More »

Why Metal for Low Slope Roofing

Learn the distinction between low slope and steep slope roofs and why metal is the most popular choice for low slope roofs. Dive into the specifics and also learn how you can receive a training certificate from one of the industry’s leading experts on the subject at METALCON 2024.

Read More »

Essential Metalworking Tools

At the heart of metalworking lies the essential tools that transform raw materials into amazing structures. Immerse yourself in the world of metalcraft as you explore these indispensable tools in this blog and by attending METALCON 2024, Some of these tools may even be celebrated as the Top Products of 2024!

Read More »

METALCON Newsletter May

EDUCATION PROGRAM ANNOUNCED FOR 2024Year after year, METALCON draws attendees hungry for more than just exhibits. They attend this annual event for an unmatched educational experience, leveling up their knowledge of products, systems, and the latest innovations. Led by industry titans in metal construction, architecture, engineering, and manufacturing, the workshops and educational sessions are meticulously crafted to cater to the unique needs of our diverse audience. Take your pick from a wealth of options: immerse yourself in intensive paid workshops,

Read More »

Trends in Architectural Metalwork

Architectural metalwork is where function and structure meet art and design, critical in today’s metal construction industry. Dive into the trends including metal ceilings, exterior metal finish, staircases and balustrades. Learn how The Architect’s Experience at METALCON can deepen your knowledge of architectural metalwork. Save $50 if you register TODAY!

Read More »

Barndominiums: Discover Benefits, Trends, & Unique Designs

“You’ll never look at a Metal Building the Same Way Again!®” says METALCON presenter, Stacee Lynn, also known as The Barndominium Lady®. In today’s #MagnificentMetalMonday, we discover the benefits, trends, and unique designs of this trending versatile, modern home known as a Barndominium. Also learn how you can see Stacee Lynn in person for her education session at METALCON 2024 in Atlanta, GA, October 30 – November 1.

Read More »